ICE AUSTIN SHOOTING LEGAL ANALYSIS
This past week, ICE agents in Austin Texas shot an illegal immigrant. The shooting was non-fatal, causing injury to the illegal alien’s upper back. This was due to a traffic stop gone wrong where officers were attempting to serve a deportation order from the DOJ. This shooting has caused massive protests in the Austin area over the week. Many are calling this another instance of “Trump’s secret police” attempting to assassinate an innocent immigrant. This could not be further from the truth. Now that we have had a week for all the details to come out, let’s take a step back and do a full legal analysis of the situation.
The shooting took place on Sunday September 20th. At approximately 12:44 PM, ICE officers made contact with the illegal immigrant in question: Mr. Wilber Rafael Garcés Pérez, a 28-year-old Venezuelan national. Mr. Pérez was driving his blue sedan and working as a Door Dash driver during the initial traffic stop interaction. According to DOJ sources, Mr. Pérez was stopped due to an official deportation order. Mr. Pérez was in the country illegally on a work order that expired in 2025. Due to this, ICE was looking for him.
A traffic stop was conducted, where Mr. Pérez was identified. Shortly after the initial interaction, Mr. Pérez drove away from the active traffic stop during his lawful detainment. This constitutes a felony charge for failure to comply with the order of a law enforcement officer. Mr. Pérez led officers on a pursuit through several neighborhoods in the area. It is important to note that law enforcement views a vehicle pursuit as ‘life threatening’. This is due to erratic driving, and desperate emotion, from the person who is running from the police. Potential fatal traffic accidents rise dramatically during pursuits, as well as the possibility of a pedestrian being struck by the fleeing vehicle. This demonstrates that the person fleeing from law enforcement is showing no due regard for the safety or life of others in his immediate area.
Eventually, Mr. Pérez’s vehicle stops under an overpass and ICE agents are able to approach the vehicle. Now, this is where the details get foggy. The ICE agents present during the time of the shooting were not wearing body cameras from what we understand at this time. Due to this, there is no footage of the exact moment of the shooting. All we can do is analyze pedestrian cell phone video, and video directly after the shooting. Some videos have been found showing a far off view of the moment of the shooting. It appears that Mr. Pérez’s vehicle was not completely stopped during the time of the shooting. You can clearly see his vehicle rolling forward during and after the shots were fired.
The video directly after the shooting shows Mr. Pérez outside the vehicle with law enforcement providing first aid. Until we receive an official statement from the ICE officer who shot Mr. Pérez, or a statement about the exact moment of the shooting from the DOJ, we cannot say what actually happened in those critical moments. This is unfortunate from an information and documentation standpoint. However, we can use context and rules of operation from law enforcement to infer what could have happened.
Something we know for sure is that Mr. Pérez was acting in a way that was putting officers, and civilians, in life threatening danger due to his actions during the pursuit. Also, it is basic law enforcement training that vehicles during a traffic stop can offer concealment to a weapon. Watch any body camera footage of a shooting during a traffic stop for proof. Someone can present a weapon and engage law enforcement with deadly force in literally less than a second of time. Officers have to evaluate that threat as valid or invalid in the exact same amount of time. If that is not done, you are either dead or lucky.
Due to Mr. Pérez’s behavior, illegal status, life threatening decisions, and commission of a felony in the presence of law enforcement, is it hard to believe that officers would be treating Mr. Pérez as a deadly threat at the moment of the shooting? Not at all. Put yourself in the shoes of the ICE agent. You just had an illegal migrant with a warrant flee from you. You chased him through residential neighborhoods where his driving was presenting potentially lethal actions against the local population. The car stops but is still rolling, showing that the chase may not be done yet. You approach the car and Mr. Pérez is making, as law enforcement puts it, potential “furtive movements”. We obviously don’t know what exactly happened at that moment when shots were fired. However, Mr. Pérez’s actions in that moment may have made ICE agents fear lethal response against them; prompting the discharge of their duty weapons.
Let’s take a look at the statements released directly from the DOJ and DHS regarding this shooting.
“The illegal alien’s work permit expired in 2025. Furthermore, a work permit does NOT grant legal status.”
“He entered illegally under the Biden Administration. The illegal alien had no valid work permit, had no protective status, and had a final order of removal from a Department of Justice (DOJ) Immigration Judge.”
“This illegal alien was the subject of a targeted vehicle stop. What makes someone a target for immigration enforcement is whether or not they are illegally in the U.S.”
“Resisting officers and evading arrest is dangerous for our officers, illegal aliens, and the public. We remind the public that resisting officers and evading arrest is a felony and a federal crime. Sanctuary politicians need to stop encouraging this dangerous behavior that puts our officers and the public at risk.”
Any loss of life is tragic, and in this case, no life was lost. It’s a miracle that nobody was struck by the fleeing vehicle, or that Mr. Perez was not killed from the bullet. Mr. Perez is now locked up in the local detention facility awaiting a court date and potential deportation. Law enforcement is a dangerous job. Hopefully we will not see more cases of illegal immigrant criminals putting law enforcement, or the public, in danger.
Related Articles
