Everybody watched Dems roll through the midterms in a massive blue wave that left Republicans licking their wounds. And naturally, everybody started talking about how MAGA had been crushed.
But a new post-election study has thrown a very dry wrench into that little storyline.
What if the biggest problem wasn’t that Trump voters suddenly fell in love with Dems and helped generate the blue wave from hell?
What if a huge chunk of the people who helped put Trump back in the White House simply couldn’t be bothered to vote for one reason or another?
That’s what a new J.L. Partners analysis is suggesting. The National Pulse shared the data, and the numbers are pretty convincing.
Basically, we’re talking about a party losing control of Congress while a huge chunk of its own voters sat at home and watched the carnage unfold.
Raheem J. Kassam:
Thirty-five per cent of Trump’s 2024 voters didn’t bother turning out for the midterms, while only eight per cent switched to the Democrats. That’s from J.L. Partners, who surveyed 1,000 registered voters and cross-checked them against more than 30,000 campaign interviews. Their founder reckons the GOP would have lost the House and the Senate even if nobody had switched sides. So much for the blue wave. The people who sat it out were older, rural and without degrees, the heart of the MAGA coalition, and if Republicans can’t get them back out by 2028 no amount of moderating will save them.
Thirty-five per cent of Trump’s 2024 voters didn’t bother turning out for the midterms, while only eight per cent switched to the Democrats. That’s from J.L. Partners, who surveyed 1,000 registered voters and cross-checked them against more than 30,000 campaign interviews. Their founder reckons the GOP would have lost the House and the Senate even if nobody had switched sides. So much for the blue wave. The people who sat it out were older, rural and without degrees, the heart of the MAGA coalition, and if Republicans can’t get them back out by 2028 no amount of moderating will save them.
— Raheem J. Kassam (@RaheemKassam) November 17, 2026
The turnout gap accounted for about 10 points of the 15-point swing that they measured. The other five points came from voters changing sides.
But the people who stayed home weren’t some tiny fringe. These were almost half of Trump’s base. The 2024 voters without college degrees and large numbers of rural and older supporters all stayed home.
J.L. Partners:
“Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House.”
That’s not just a “blue wave.” This is a different kind of political problem. If your voters actually switch teams, you need to figure out what changed their minds. If they don’t show up at all, you have to ask why you couldn’t get them off the couch, especially when this election was so crucial.
Midterms have always been a different kind of animal from presidential elections. Far fewer Americans show up when the White House isn’t on the ballot. And the party holding the presidency often has the toughest time.
Remember 2010 and 2014? Those were big midterm gains for the GOP. But Obama was sitting in the White House back then, and Republicans were fired up to take power away from the Dems.
And that’s usually how midterms go. The party holding the White House tends to get its butt kicked, while the opposition shows up ready for a fight. In 2010, Obama’s Dems lost a whopping 63 House seats. In 2014, they lost another 13 House seats and nine Senate seats.
So Republicans getting absolutely clobbered in 2026 isn’t exactly some new phenomenon. The more important question is why so many Trump voters decided to sit this one out.
And we’ve seen something similar before. In 2018, during Trump’s first term, Dems also benefited from somewhat stronger turnout among the people who had backed Hillary Clinton two years earlier.
PEW:
“Slightly more of Clinton’s than Trump’s voters turned out to vote in 2018.”
Pew found 78% of Clinton’s 2016 voters turned out again in 2018, compared with 74% of Trump’s.
Trump has always had this remarkable ability to get people off the couch and into the voting booth, even people who don’t normally bother with elections. But this time, that magic didn’t work. And we think there’s a reason for that.
A good chunk of Trump’s voters are likely angry, disappointed, or just plain fed up with how things have been going. Whatever their reasons, they didn’t show up, and Republicans paid the price.
That’s something Team Trump needs to figure out before 2028.
But some Trump voters really did flip. Who were they?
The research also identified people who voted for Trump in 2024 and then switched to Democrats in 2026. That group is nowhere near as big as the folks who stayed home, but it’s still really important because we’re talking about younger voters, the very people Republicans had been celebrating for moving in their direction during the last presidential election.
National Pulse:
Which Trump Voters Backed the Democrats?
Young, male, urban, and non-white voters who backed Trump in 2024 were more likely to switch during the midterms.
Trump voters between ages 18 and 29 were particularly likely to flip, with 16 percent defecting to the Democrats. In contrast, eight percent of Trump voters between 30 and 49 defected to the Democrats, along with four percent of Trump voters between 50 and 64 and six percent of Trump voters over 65.
Defectors were responsible for an additional five-point swing away from the Republicans during the elections.
Yowza. Sixteen percent of Trump’s youngest voters switching sides is red flags flying. But the overall picture is still dominated by all those missing voters. So, what happened between the excitement of 2024 and the empty polling places in 2026?
The economy never took off, and the Iran war showed up. Those two things are the likely culprits, according to what many experts are seeing in the post-mortem polling and research.
But, all that aside, Dems spent two years working their tails off. What was the GOP doing all that time?
There’s another piece to this story, and it’s the one Ed Martin talked about on his show with Chris Moreno, a former Dem operative turned Republican strategist. Moreno’s argument is that Dems spent nearly two years building a network to reach independents and people who don’t usually vote, while Republicans fizzled.
Ed Martin:
REPUBLICANS HAD THE MONEY… SO HOW DID DEMOCRATS OUTORGANIZE THEM AND PULL OFF A BLUE WAVE?! 🚨🔥
Former Dem operative turned GOP strategist Chris Moreno joined me with a STUNNING breakdown of what went wrong.
Chris says Dems spent nearly TWO YEARS targeting independent and low-turnout voters through a sophisticated network of nonprofits and political groups.
Meanwhile, Republican leadership was caught flat-footed, and the GOP Senate dragged its feet on Trump’s agenda.
DID REPUBLICANS GET OUTSMARTED, OUTWORKED… OR BOTH?
We dug into the political machinery behind the midterms on “Early Bird With Ed Martin,” on@RealAmVoice!
WATCH! 👇
REPUBLICANS HAD THE MONEY… SO HOW DID DEMOCRATS OUTORGANIZE THEM AND PULL OFF A BLUE WAVE?! 🚨🔥
Former Dem operative turned GOP strategist Chris Moreno joined me with a STUNNING breakdown of what went wrong.
Chris says Dems spent nearly TWO YEARS targeting independent and low-turnout voters through a sophisticated network of nonprofits and political groups.
Meanwhile, Republican leadership was caught flat-footed, and the GOP Senate dragged its feet on Trump’s agenda.
DID REPUBLICANS GET OUTSMARTED, OUTWORKED… OR BOTH?
We dug into the political machinery behind the midterms on “Early Bird With Ed Martin,” on @RealAmVoice!
WATCH! 👇
— Eagle Ed Martin (@EagleEdMartin) November 18, 2026
If Moreno’s right, that makes the turnout numbers even more stomach-turning. Dems didn’t just get lucky because Republicans stayed home. They’d spent nearly two years busting their asses, organizing and finding voters who might otherwise sit out the election.
And judging by the results, all that work paid off. Their massive organizing efforts – which they’re good at – played a big role in creating that blue wave.
Meanwhile, Republicans had a ton of money, a sitting president, and a full understanding of what was at stake. Yet somehow, Dems still managed to outwork them.
That’s a pretty ugly political lesson.
What happens next matters more than the finger-pointing.
The National Pulse also looked at the smaller group of Trump voters who switched parties, including what they say they’re worried about. The cost of living comes through loud and clear. If Republicans want a real answer to what went wrong, they might start there instead of assuming every unhappy voter wants some massive ideological makeover.
National Pulse:
This polling underscores the importance of base turnout in winning elections, as opposed to moderating key policies.
“If Republicans can energize their 2024 vote in 2028, then they may yet have a shot at winning again,” said Johnson.
According to recent polling from Navigator Research, a project of the Democrat-aligned Global Strategy Group, “Trump defectors” who supported the President in 2024 but voted Democrat in 2026 have a negative view of the far-left Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). The same polling revealed that 48 percent of “Trump defectors” were primarily concerned with the rising cost of living.
This suggests that far-left policies, such as abolishing U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and defunding the police, are not popular with voters who switched to the Democrats.
People are going to vote based on whether they believe DC is making their lives better. They have bills to pay, and groceries cost too much. They remember the campaign promises, and they notice when those promises aren’t coming through.
Republicans need to figure out why so many of their 2024 voters decided a trip to the polls wasn’t worth it this time.
You can read the entire National Pulse article here.
