Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito issued a chilling warning on Thursday that should alarm every American, regardless of which political party they support.
Advertisement
Because if his warning comes true, life in America will fundamentally change, and not for the better.
Alito warned that Congress could effectively prevent the nation’s highest court from functioning by cutting off its funding, raising concerns about growing political pressure on the supposedly independent judiciary.
Alito delivered the warning during remarks at the Federalist Society’s Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner in Washington, where he discussed judicial independence and the constitutional separation of powers.
Advertisement
The conservative justice said the Supreme Court depends on Congress for funding necessary to perform its constitutional responsibilities.
“If you defund the courts, you destroy judicial independence,” Alito said.
Alito noted that while Article III of the Constitution protects federal judges from having their salaries reduced while in office, that protection does not extend to the broader judicial branch budget.
Congress controls appropriations for court employees, security, buildings and other resources necessary for the federal judiciary to operate.
Alito said lawmakers theoretically could exploit that authority to make it extremely difficult for the Supreme Court to function.
“If courts are not independent, then they cannot perform the function that the Constitution assigns to them,” Alito said.
His comments come amid an increasingly contentious political debate surrounding the Supreme Court and its 6-3 conservative majority.
Democratic lawmakers have introduced proposals in recent years to impose new ethics requirements on the justices, expand congressional oversight and make other structural changes to the court.
Some Democrats have also discussed using Congress’ spending authority to pressure the Supreme Court over ethics and transparency disputes.
Republicans have accused Democrats of attempting to intimidate the judiciary because of disagreements with major rulings.
Democrats supporting court reforms argue that Congress has legitimate constitutional authority to regulate aspects of the federal judiciary and say stronger ethics and transparency requirements are necessary.
Advertisement
Alito did not argue that Congress lacks constitutional authority over judicial appropriations.
Instead, his warning focused on what could happen if lawmakers used that authority as leverage against judges because they disagreed with court decisions.
The Supreme Court receives its operating budget through congressional appropriations like other parts of the federal government.
Advertisement
Federal judges themselves enjoy specific constitutional protections intended to insulate them from political retaliation.
Article III provides that federal judges hold office during “good Behaviour” and that their compensation cannot be diminished while they remain in office.
Those protections were designed to prevent Congress or the executive branch from directly threatening judges’ livelihoods over unpopular decisions.
They do not prevent Congress from determining how much money is provided for broader court operations.
Alito’s comments also came as Democrats prepare to take control of the House in January following their midterm victories.
Republicans will retain control of the Senate, creating divided government and limiting Democrats’ ability to enact major changes to the Supreme Court without Republican support.
Advertisement
The House nevertheless possesses significant investigative and appropriations powers that Democrats could use to increase scrutiny of the judiciary.
Alito has become increasingly outspoken about threats he believes could undermine judicial independence.
In recent interviews, the George W. Bush appointee has defended the court against accusations that its conservative majority operates as a political institution.
Alito was nominated by Bush in 2005 and confirmed by the Senate in January 2006.
He has since become one of the court’s most consistently conservative members and authored the majority opinion in the 2022 Dobbs decision overturning Roe v. Wade.
The Supreme Court has faced intense political scrutiny since its conservative majority expanded to 6-3 during Trump’s first term.
Alito argued Thursday that Americans should be able to criticize judicial decisions while preserving the institutional independence necessary for judges to rule without political retaliation.
This article may contain commentary which reflects the author’s opinion.
