Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman said he could reconsider his future in the Democratic Party if Maryland Sen. Chris Van Hollen defeats Chuck Schumer in the increasingly contentious race to lead Senate Democrats.
Advertisement
Fetterman made the comments Saturday during an appearance on Fox News’ “Saturday in America,” where host Kayleigh McEnany asked whether Democrats could cross a “red line” that would cause him to leave the party.
“Yeah, absolutely,” Fetterman responded.
“It would be troubling if my caucus elects someone like Van Hollen that has really made his name being very anti-hostile to Israel, you know,” Fetterman said.
Advertisement
“If you are going to be angry or hostile towards any countries in the region, why not make that, you know, Iran or Hezbollah or Hamas as well too?”
Fetterman also criticized Democratic efforts to restrict American support for Israel.
“Why, both in the House, now in the Senate, now their first instincts are to punish Israel and to withhold these kinds of aid. Why?” Fetterman asked.
“Why isn’t your first instinct to say, ‘Let’s hold Iran accountable?’”
McEnany pressed Fetterman on whether Van Hollen’s election would actually cause him to abandon the party.
Fetterman stopped short of making that commitment.
“Well, I don’t know how that’s going to look, but I am a Democrat,” he said.
“I’ve always said that.”
WATCH:
🚨 BREAKING NEWS: In @SenFettermanPA’s first interview since the midterm election, Fetterman encourages Democrats to “take the win” and pursue bipartisanship to solve the problems of the American people rather than “turn it into a circus of constant hearings and about payback.”
“That’s a lost opportunity❗️,” he said.
When I asked him whether he would leave the Democratic Party if Senator Van Hollen became Majority Leader, he called out Van Hollen’s “anti-Israel kinds of views,” calling him a “progressive darling” and pointing out that he’s best known for his meeting with Kilmar Abrego Garcia.
Fetterman also told me his “red line” for leaving the party in his first interview since the midterm elections on @SatAmericaFNC @FoxNews ⬇️
— Kayleigh McEnany (@kayleighmcenany) November 14, 2026
The comments nevertheless represent another significant break between Fetterman and the progressive wing of his party, particularly over Israel.
Fetterman has been one of Israel’s most outspoken Democratic supporters since Hamas’ Oct. 7, 2023, terrorist attack and has frequently criticized Democrats seeking restrictions on U.S. military assistance.
Advertisement
Van Hollen has taken a markedly different approach, repeatedly criticizing Israeli government policies and questioning aspects of American military support.
The Maryland Democrat announced Thursday that he would challenge Schumer for the top Democratic leadership position when senators hold their leadership election.
“In this election, Americans called on us to unrig an economy rigged against working people & fueled by political corruption,” Van Hollen said.
“To deliver, we need new leadership.”
Advertisement
“This isn’t about any one person – it’s about answering that call. That’s why I’m running.”
The contest has quickly exposed significant divisions among Senate Democrats.
Independent Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, who caucuses with Democrats, announced that he would not support Schumer for another term and backed Van Hollen.
Van Hollen said Sunday that he has a path to winning the leadership contest and claimed support from 15 senators, while Schumer has maintained that he has enough votes to remain leader.
Fetterman is firmly supporting Schumer.
“I’m going to support Schumer,” Fetterman said during a separate Fox News appearance.
“I absolutely disagree with some of the things that he’s done, but he’s always been strongly pro-Israel.”
Advertisement
Fetterman has increasingly separated himself from progressive Democrats on immigration, Israel, Iran and other issues while demonstrating a willingness to work with President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans.
He has repeatedly rejected speculation that he intends to become a Republican.
Fetterman also warned Democrats against using their congressional power primarily to investigate Trump.
He cautioned against turning the next two years “into a circus of constant hearings” focused on political “payback.”
The Pennsylvania senator faces his own political challenges ahead of his 2028 reelection campaign, including opposition from Democrats unhappy with his positions on Israel and other issues.
For now, Fetterman continues to identify himself as a Democrat.
But his comments Saturday made clear that the outcome of the Schumer-Van Hollen leadership fight could force him to reconsider how much political ground he still shares with his party.
This article may contain commentary which reflects the author’s opinion.
