Home > KASH PATEL
58 views 6 min 0 Comment

Judge mulls throwing out DOJ’s leak case against James Comey

adrianoreid@hotmail.com - October 31, 2026


A federal judge seemed skeptical Friday of the way the Justice Department has mounted its third attempt to prosecute former FBI Director James Comey, but signaled he may await further action by prosecutors rather than throwing out the pending charges immediately.

U.S. District Judge Trevor McFadden heard arguments for over an hour on charges stemming from an alleged leak of classified information a decade ago. Comey’s lawyers say the 10-year statute of limitations for those charges has expired.

Prosecutors filed a pair of felony charges earlier this month over disclosures to The New York Times in 2016 about surveillance practices. However, the Justice Department brought the case through what’s known as a criminal information, a procedure allowing them to temporarily sidestep securing a grand jury indictment. Prosecutors say that effectively satisfied the statute of limitations, but Comey’s attorneys say the government needed to get an indictment by that deadline and failed to do so.

“The government is wrong. The statute of limitations has run,” Comey lawyer Ephraim McDowell said.

Comey was not in the courtroom for the hearing in federal court in Washington and has not been arrested on the charges: one count of disclosing national defense information and one count of conspiring to do so. In a video posted online Monday, Comey said he is innocent.

McFadden, a Trump appointee, did not rule Friday. However, he seemed to lean toward the defense’s position that the word “indictment” in the special 10-year statute-of-limitations provision for national security crimes means indictment, rather than the government’s more complex interpretation that the word encompasses other means of bringing a criminal case.

“I think of myself as a pretty formalistic judge,” the judge said.

But McFadden also threw a curveball into the session by suggesting he might put off ruling and see whether prosecutors can get an indictment. If they fail to do so, the statute-of-limitations issue would be moot, the judge said. He also alluded to the fact that prosecutors have encountered resistance to a series of indictments in Washington over the past two years.

“It turns out ham sandwiches are harder to indict these days,” the judge quipped. “Grand juries do surprising things.”

“What harm would your client suffer here if I delayed ruling until we see if the government can even return an indictment?” McFadden asked McDowell, noting that the defense could renew its arguments about the statute of limitations after an indictment comes in, if there is one.

McDowell responded that FBI agents have been “stationed outside Mr. Comey’s house” and that the threat of being arrested at any time “is hanging over Mr. Comey’s head.”

“Just letting this hang out there, pending, is a very unfair and unjust result,” the defense lawyer said. He also noted that the 2016 report at the center of the new charge was investigated twice by the Justice Department with no charges being filed, before the Trump administration decided to dig into the issue again.

The prosecution also had some surprises to share. A Texas-based prosecutor assigned to the case, Dustin Farahnak, said that it was possible the grand jury might decide the conspiracy in which Comey is accused of participating involved actions taken as late as April 2017. That would mean the 10-year window to pursue the conspiracy charge remains open.

The leak charges filed in Washington earlier this month follow an indictment the Justice Department obtained against Comey in North Carolina in April for allegedly threatening Trump’s life by posting a photo on Instagram last year of seashells arranged on a beach to read “86 47.”

In another case last year, federal prosecutors in Virginia charged Comey with making false statements and obstruction of Congress in connection with testimony he gave in 2020. That case was dismissed after a judge ruled that the U.S. attorney involved was illegally appointed. The Justice Department is appealing that ruling.

In both of those cases, Comey’s lawyers sought to have the charges dismissed on grounds of selective and vindictive prosecution, arguing that prosecutors were essentially carrying out a political vendetta on behalf of President Donald Trump. Trump has repeatedly denounced Comey, accusing him of amplifying false allegations about Trump’s ties to Russia and prompting the special counsel investigation that dogged Trump during his first term.

As the court session closed Friday, McFadden seemed to acknowledge the administration’s hostility towards Comey by warning that dramatic action against him would not sit well with the court.

“I will be extremely frustrated if there’s some sort of dawn raid or black pajamas outside Mr. Comey’s house,” the judge said.

“That’s not going to happen,” Farahnak said. “We’re not going to do anything that would offend the court.”

CORRECTION: A previous version of this report misstated when a prosecutor said Comey’s alleged actions took place. It was April 2017.



Source link

Views: 71

PREVIOUS

Office of Public Affairs | Indian National Pleads Guilty to $227M Medicare Fraud

NEXT

Democrat Rep. Jim Hines Threatens Elon Musk, Says Democrats Have War Gamed Fantasy Violent Election Day Chaos Caused by Musk Manipulating Algorithms That Causes Armed Citizens to Attack Polling Places
Related Post
January 14, 2026
Hearing on the Investigation of the January 6 Pipe Bomber
September 29, 2026
Senator Josh Hawley Confronts former Special Prosecutor Jack Smith During Explosive Senate Committee Hearing
March 11, 2025
Abbey Gate terrorist, human smuggling ring leaders, cartel bosses among Bondi DOJ’s first-month successes
February 24, 2026
Far-Left NPR’s Trump/Epstein ‘Bombshell’ Is Another Hoax
Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

John Michael Chambers
© 2026 John Michael Chambers All rights reserved.