Federal investigators began examining allegations that Rep. Ilhan Omar, D-Minn., entered a fraudulent marriage with a man alleged to be her brother years before President Donald Trump returned to office, according to new reporting that places the origins of the investigation during Barack Obama’s presidency.
Advertisement
Fox News Digital reported Thursday that the FBI and Department of Homeland Security opened an investigation in 2016 into allegations surrounding Omar’s 2009 marriage to Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, whom critics have long alleged was her brother and whom Omar has consistently said was not related to her.
The investigation reportedly began as Omar was emerging in Minnesota politics and ultimately examined whether the marriage was arranged to obtain an immigration benefit, an allegation that has followed the Minnesota Democrat for roughly a decade.
Advertisement
According to Fox, investigators in 2016 “found some evidence that [the marriage] was fraudulent,” but the inquiry did not produce criminal charges.
The new reporting is significant because Omar and her allies have portrayed the current federal scrutiny of her immigration history as politically motivated retaliation from the Trump administration, while the reported 2016 investigation originated under a Democratic administration.
The historical record, however, contains an important complication because then-U.S. Attorney for Minnesota Andrew Luger, an Obama appointee, publicly denied in August 2016 that his office was investigating Omar or had requested an investigation into her immigration status.
“There is no truth to this report and my office is not investigating, nor have we requested an investigation into Ms. Omar,” Luger wrote to Omar’s attorney after a local television report claimed his office had sought an immigration investigation.
The latest Fox report says the FBI and DHS investigation nevertheless existed independently of Luger’s office and that federal investigators subsequently referred information to prosecutors for review.
Fox reported that the matter eventually reached federal prosecutors in Minnesota and was later closed in 2021 under the Biden administration, when Luger had again been nominated to serve as U.S. attorney for Minnesota.
The decision not to pursue charges reportedly involved concerns about applicable statutes of limitations, although closing an investigation without charges did not constitute a finding that the underlying allegations were true.
Advertisement
Omar legally married Elmi in Minnesota in February 2009 after previously having a religious marriage with Ahmed Hirsi, with whom she had children, and Omar has said her relationship with Elmi ended in 2011 before their legal divorce was finalized in 2017.
Advertisement
Omar later legally married Hirsi, and when allegations surfaced in 2016 that Elmi was actually her brother, she called the claims “absurd and offensive,” while later describing broader allegations of marriage and immigration fraud as “disgusting lies.”
Publicly available records have never independently established that Elmi is Omar’s brother, and earlier Associated Press reporting noted that resolving the allegation was difficult because immigration records, Somali birth records and other documentation capable of establishing family relationships were unavailable publicly.
The newly disclosed history has become particularly relevant because Omar is again under federal investigation in 2026, with investigators examining immigration records involving both the congresswoman and members of her family.
Homeland Security Investigations agents searched Omar’s Washington, D.C., residence on Oct. 12 as part of an ongoing criminal investigation involving immigration paperwork, according to sources familiar with the matter.
Advertisement
Federal investigators have also subpoenaed Omar’s sister, Sahra Noor, and other relatives while examining possible fraud or false statements connected to the family’s immigration history, although subpoenas and searches do not establish criminal wrongdoing.
Investigators are reportedly examining whether Omar’s late father, Nur Omar Mohamed, provided inaccurate or incomplete information in immigration documents before becoming a U.S. citizen, an issue that could potentially affect questions surrounding Omar’s derivative citizenship depending on what investigators ultimately establish.
Omar arrived in the United States as a refugee after her family fled Somalia’s civil war and became a naturalized American citizen in 2000, when she was a teenager.
The current investigation has also renewed scrutiny of a discrepancy involving Omar’s publicly listed birth year, which her congressional staff asked the Minnesota Legislative Reference Library to change from 1981 to 1982 in 2019.
This article may contain commentary which reflects the author’s opinion.
