The Supreme Court agreed Friday to hear a challenge to one of President Donald Trump’s key second-term immigration enforcement policies.
Advertisement
At issue is Trump’s suspension of asylum access and other legal protections for migrants who illegally cross the southern border.
The administration has kept enforcing the directive while the case proceeds, even after two lower courts ruled against it.
The policy applies to migrants crossing between official ports of entry, where the president suspended entry through a proclamation.
Advertisement
Trump issued that proclamation on his first day back in office, declaring there was an “invasion” at the southern border.
The Department of Homeland Security then issued guidance instructing immigration officials how to carry out the president’s directive.
Authorities have relied on that guidance to remove covered migrants without giving them a chance to apply for asylum.
The directive also bars those migrants from pursuing other protections that could allow them to stay in the United States.
The Supreme Court’s decision to take the case gives Trump’s administration a chance to defend that approach before the justices.
Friday’s action sets up a review of the president’s authority, with a decision expected by late June or early July next year.
The challenge began in February 2025, when three nonprofit groups and 13 individuals sued over the proclamation and enforcement guidance.
They filed a class action in federal court, challenging the rules that immigration authorities were using to process covered migrants.
Several months later, U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss ruled against the administration and set aside its restrictions on asylum.
Moss concluded that neither the Constitution nor federal immigration law authorized the administration to replace procedures Congress had enacted.
He also concluded that the president lacked unilateral authority to limit applications for asylum or other protections from noncitizens.
Moss certified a class covering people subject to the proclamation and blocked the administration from enforcing the directive against them.
Advertisement
That ruling addressed the policy across the class, extending the relief beyond the individual plaintiffs who originally filed the lawsuit.
The administration appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, where a divided panel ruled.
In April, two judges on that panel upheld Moss’s ruling and concluded that the administration had exceeded its authority.
Advertisement
The majority found that the president lacked the power to suspend asylum applications from migrants covered by the policy.
It also rejected the administration’s use of the new summary removal procedures to deport migrants covered by the directive.
The appeals court subsequently put its ruling against Homeland Security on hold pending review by the Supreme Court.
That pause has allowed immigration authorities to continue applying the directive as the administration challenges the lower courts’ conclusions.
The dispute asks the justices to weigh Trump’s use of presidential authority against the immigration procedures Congress put in place.
The case also tests the guidance Homeland Security put in place to carry out the proclamation at the southern border.
Trump made cracking down on illegal immigration central to his second term and expanded enforcement in major American cities.
Advertisement
His administration has carried out mass deportations of people in the United States illegally as part of that broader effort.
Illegal crossings at the U.S.-Mexico border have reached historic lows during Trump’s second term, according to CBS News.
Immigration detentions have also reached new highs under the administration, CBS News reported in its coverage of the enforcement campaign.
The asylum fight joins two other major immigration cases the justices are considering during the coming months.
One involves the administration’s authority to send migrants to countries other than their own, a practice known as third-country deportation.
Another concerns whether the administration can keep immigrants in the country illegally detained indefinitely without a hearing to seek bond, CBS News reported.
Those cases focus on detention and deportation decisions, while Friday’s case concerns access to asylum and related protections after crossing.
This article may contain commentary which reflects the author’s opinion.
