Subscribe to the ad-free edition
Contribute
Sign up for the email list
Well, that was ugly.
There’s no fun or clever way to dress up what happened Tuesday night. Republicans lost control of the House and Senate in horrifically spectacular fashion. Dems flipped seats in places that were supposed to be safe Republican strongholds, including a gut punch in Texas and South Carolina. The House losses have already climbed past two dozen, and will likely go higher. Dems also flipped at least seven Senate seats, with some still being counted.
And after all the chatter about weaponized polls, the experts supposedly getting it wrong again, and prediction markets allegedly being bought off by Democrats, Election Night finally arrived and delivered the gruesome truth.
It just wasn’t the truth a lot of Republicans wanted to hear.
The polls got it right. Many Republicans got it wrong. Oddly enough, the mainstream polls actually underestimated the Democrats. Probably because they were afraid of having a huge miss again.
There’s plenty of blame to go around after a night like that, and a whole lot of frustration to unpack. But before we get into who dropped the ball and why, it’s worth looking at what the voters actually told us. And as it turns out, they had plenty to say. First, though, a little historical perspective on midterm elections might help put this political disaster into some kind of context.
HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
Yes, the party holding the White House usually gets hammered in the midterms. That’s a well-established historical pattern, but it would be a serious mistake to hide behind it while the political wreckage from Tuesday night is still being counted. Some defeats are considerably worse than others, and this one could wind up among the ugliest in modern political history.
And the warning signs were there long before Election Day.
Trump’s approval rating was scraping the bottom of the barrel. A Reuters/Ipsos poll released just before the election put him at a miserable 32 percent, near the lowest mark of his political career. That’s a staggering number for a president whose party was already struggling with frustrated voters, an unpopular war, and growing dissatisfaction with the direction of the country.
This poll had him at 34 percent, which is obviously still ghastly.
Now, for some historical perspective, look at Barack Obama’s miserable midterm track record. In 2010, Democrats lost 63 House seats and six Senate seats, handing Republicans control of the House in the Tea Party wave. Four years later, Obama watched his party lose another 13 House seats and nine Senate seats, surrendering control of that chamber, too. Two absolute midterm bloodbaths for Barry.
Trump’s first midterm in 2018 wasn’t pretty, either. Republicans lost roughly 40 House seats, although they managed to gain two in the Senate. It was a punishing rebuke that cost the GOP control of the House and gave Democrats the power to make the next two years of Trump’s presidency a hellish nightmare.
Then came Joe Biden’s surprisingly meh 2022 midterm. Dems lost nine House seats and actually gained a Senate seat, despite the country wrestling with inflation and economic frustration.
But here’s the thing about presidents like Obama and Trump: They inspire a lot of passion, both for and against them. Their supporters are fiercely loyal, but their opponents are just as determined to show up and deliver a political beat down. But Biden was about as exciting as a bowl of room-temp oatmeal. He never generated any fever-pitch political love or hatred, which might explain why his midterm losses were mild.
But even that explanation only gets us so far.
Because Tuesday wasn’t just another situation with an unpopular president getting roughed up by an energized “resistance.” Republicans were staring at collapsing approval ratings, voters who were furious about their finances, and infighting within their own movement. And if the remaining House races break badly enough, the final losses could make Obama’s notorious 2010 shellacking look like a cake walk.
In all honesty, this could end up being the worst political shellacking since 1932.
And that’s what makes this election so troubling. There’s a difference between the usual midterm punishment and a party discovering that huge numbers of Americans, including people who helped put it in power, have become deeply dissatisfied with what it’s doing.
And that’s where this autopsy really begins.
BLUE WAVE OR RED PUDDLE?
Honestly, we can call it a blue wave and a red puddle, because the evidence points in both directions.
Dems were seriously energized, and Republicans weren’t matching that energy at all. And in key places, voters who were willing to back Trump in 2024 weren’t willing to give Republican congressional candidates the same support two years later.
In Texas, rural Hispanics came out in droves for Talarico.
And speaking of the Hispanic vote, it deserves a closer look, because something pretty dramatic happened there. In 2024, Democrats carried Hispanic voters by just five points. Two years later, that margin jumped to 27 points in the House midterms, wiping away most of the ground Trump gained.
But here’s the big question: How much of that reversal came from Trump-supporting Hispanics staying home, and how much came from voters actually switching sides? It’s possible both played a role.
This lack of support was out there for everybody to see. Many just didn’t want to believe it.
An Ipsos survey taken just before Election Day found Dem registered voters way more enthusiastic about voting than Republicans. We’re talking 56 percent to 37 percent. That’s insane. Gallup also found a big an enthusiasm advantage for Democrats.
IPSOS:
Democratic registered voters show more significantly more enthusiasm about voting in this year’s midterms than their Republican counterparts (56% vs. 37%).
But turnout doesn’t explain the entire map.
Early AP voter research also found Republicans losing ground with younger and Hispanic voters compared with Trump’s 2024 team. And you’ve gotta wonder how much losing Charlie Kirk played into that, especially with the younger voters he worked so hard to reach and energize.
You’ll notice that Boomer happiness is at an all-time high.
The only age group Republicans actually won was 65+
Gen X split
And voter under 45 felt totally alienated by the GOP https://t.co/eQqogSp1ot
— Jack Posobiec (@JackPosobiec) November 4, 2026
Clearly, it’s the golden age if you’re sitting on a 401(k), real estate assets, and are on Medicare. Meanwhile, everybody else feels screwed.
Losing ground with younger voters hurt, and while Turning Point USA is still working hard, Charlie Kirk’s absence raises another question worth considering. Charlie had his finger on the pulse of younger conservatives, but he also had Trump’s ear. He understood the frustrations brewing with young voters and wasn’t shy about speaking up. You have to wonder if he were still here, would he have recognized the growing anger early enough to bring it to Trump’s attention.
Sadly, we’ll never know. But what we can do is take a closer look at why so many Americans were eager to punish the party in power. And the best place to start is with the frustrations voters have been screaming about for months, and falling on deaf ears.
IT’S THE ECONOMY, STUPID
Trump came back to Washington promising to get America’s economy roaring again. But a lot of families are still looking at grocery bills, rent, utilities, and the gas pump and wondering when the relief is coming.
And if you’re wondering just how badly Trump’s economic message has lost its shine, take a look at this rather horrifying graph from The Economist and YouGov.
During his first term, Trump’s approval on the economy hovered in mostly positive territory. But this time around, it’s been a steady march downhill, with his net approval on the economy plunging to a miserable negative 36 points.
That’s a staggering reversal for a president who once made economic prosperity one of his biggest selling points. And it helps explain why so many voters weren’t very interested in hearing that better days were just around the corner.
The populist message we won on, has gone oddly silent, except the left has picked it up, and is now running with it.
Democrats are gleefully embracing populism while the GOP has done everything it could to expel populism from its party these past two years. https://t.co/dE6FBgJaXo
— Douglass Mackey (@douglassmackey) November 4, 2026
Exit polls revealed that the economy was the most important issue for 39 percent of voters.
Take a look at how Americans are feeling about Trump’s tariffs, one of the cornerstones of his economic agenda.
According to this polling, a whopping 64 percent believe his tariffs have actually hurt the national economy, while just 22 percent think they’ve helped. And the frustration hits even closer to home, with 63 percent saying the tariffs have hurt the economy in their own communities.
That’s a pretty painful verdict on a policy Trump has spent years championing as a way to revive American industry, protect jobs, and bring prosperity back home.
And when voters are already struggling to make ends meet, convincing them that it’ll pay off “soon” becomes a much harder sell.
In terms of other important issues, another 32 percent chose the rather vague category of “the state of democracy,” which could mean anything from election integrity and government corruption to concerns about presidential power, depending on who’s answering. Immigration was at 14 percent, with healthcare at 8 percent.
Foreign policy came in at just four percent, but that doesn’t mean the Iran war wasn’t a factor. Voters can be angry about many things at once, and wars have a habit of showing up in stuff like fuel prices, household budgets, and yes, even that wonderfully vague category of “the state of democracy.”
But yeah, it’s always the economy, isn’t it? Because nearly nine in ten voters said the cost of living was a crucial or major factor in their decision. Roughly three-quarters were dissatisfied or angry with the direction of the country. Those are some brutal numbers, and they paint a pretty clear picture of just how unhappy Americans are with the way things are going.
CBS News:
Voters are feeling it in their pocketbooks.
It’s very possible for an average independent or run-of-the-mill Republican voter to still support Trump’s tough stance on the border while being furious about the cost of living, the war, and a Republican-controlled Congress that doesn’t seem to be doing jack sh*t.
And sure, some more politically engaged people will wonder why anybody who cares about border security would vote for a Dem or sit out an election that could hand Dems more power. It’s a fair question. But voters don’t always understand or weigh every political consequence when they’re angry. Some don’t even connect the dots, while others know perfectly well what’s at stake and simply have other priorities. And then there are the people who’ve become so fed up with their own party that withholding their vote feels like the only way to make themselves heard.
That doesn’t mean they’ve suddenly embraced the Democrats’ immigration policies. It means their frustration with Republicans has become a massive part of the equation and they don’t know what else to do.
IRAN AND THE AMERICA FIRST FRACTURE
Then there’s Iran, the issue some people in conservative media, like Mark Levin and Ben Shapiro seemed desperate to wave away.
The hardcore MAGA base remained intensely loyal to Trump. But loyalty to the president doesn’t mean unconditional enthusiasm for every decision his admin makes. For some voters, America’s involvement in yet another Middle East war collided head-on with what America First means.
A lot of these voters didn’t sign up for another open-ended foreign mess. They wanted jobs, a stronger economy, a secure border, and a government that finally put their own problems ahead of everybody else’s. Whether one supports the Iran operation or not, it’s not hard to see why some would ask how a war fits into that promise.
And there’s actual polling behind these concern. Pew’s October research dealt some very somber news to Trump on the Iran front.
Pew Research Center:
About three-quarters of Americans (77%) expect the conflict to last another six months or more.
Maybe the admin expected a quick operation. Maybe Trump’s advisers promised one. What we do know is that the public’s patience with another drawn out Middle East conflict is really limited.
And Trump probably realized that, because on Election Day he announced an agreement to end roughly $4 billion in annual aid to Israel. That was a major announcement, though the precise implementation and Congress’s role are still iffy. It also arrived very late in an election that was already shaped by anger about the war.
Too little, too late? Yes.
And perhaps the timing a little too perfect? Was it done to quiet critics who believed Washington was putting Israel ahead of Americans? After the shellacking Tuesday night, it’s fair to ask.
And that brings us to the people who’ve been doing an awful lot of lecturing about what MAGA voters are and aren’t allowed to think.
THE MARK LEVIN PROBLEM
Israel First champion Mark Levin has been one of the loudest conservative voices defending the admins Iran policy and attacking anybody who isn’t on board with it. Obviously, we don’t know what his private chats with Trump were, but his loud and proud public message has been impossible to miss.
Just before the election, we published a piece on Levin and his paranoia over polls indicating low Republican turnout. Levin was an emotional mess, crying and insisting that any potential Republican turnout problems shouldn’t be blamed on Iran. The piece was written before the results came in, which makes all of this even more relevant. Did Mark know we were facing down a bloodbath?
Revolver:
So if some Republican voters are angry about the admin’s foreign policy, wouldn’t that be something worth discussing?
Apparently not if you’re Cryin’ Mark Levin.
He’s already assuring everybody that the Iran war has absolutely nothing to do with any potential Republican losses, even though he hasn’t officially polled anybody.
And the way he delivers this little lecture is really something to behold.
Levin is really irritated with conservatives who feel the Trump admin hasn’t delivered everything they expected. And instead of honestly debating the issue, he dismisses any complaints, defends the president’s handling of Iran, and insists that most Americans have been virtually unaffected by the war.
Again, where is Mark getting his information from?
Then he starts rattling off states where Republican turnout is reportedly looking weak. But again, instead of examining what might be keeping voters away, he announces that any potential defeat comes down to one thing: Democrats showing up in greater numbers.
And again, just in case anybody was thinking about blaming the Iran war, Levin makes sure to knock that idea down.
This is a piece worth reading:
Mark Levin CRYING…
Well, Mark, the horrific results are in, and even Trump has acknowledged that Iran played a part in the bloodbath.
Reuters:
President Donald Trump acknowledged on Wednesday that the US-Israeli war on Iran played a role in his party’s sweeping defeat in the midterm elections, as Democrats won control of the House of Representatives and the Senate.
“I think a part of it was Iran,” Trump told Fox News in an interview; “Iran was a piece of it,” he separately told The Wall Street Journal.
That doesn’t make the war the only explanation, but it certainly raises an awkward question for people like Mark Levin who were so confident the issue didn’t matter that treated dissenting conservatives like disloyal troublemakers who should be voted off the MAGA island.
There’s a big difference between defending a policy and telling voters their frustrations don’t matter. And when influential voices spend months scolding the Republicans they need to show up at the polls, they shouldn’t act shocked, or start crying, when some of those voters finally throw up their hands and check out.
President Trump’s advisers and allies let him down on the Iran war, and Mark Levin, whatever role he may have played behind the scenes, certainly dug in and did his part publicly. He turned the issue into a loyalty test, berating conservatives who dared to question the war or suggest it might be hurting Republicans politically.
An America First movement can’t stay healthy when its own voters are treated like troublemakers for asking who benefits from a foreign war. But Levin has made his priorities on Israel pretty clear, so what does he care?
THE PROMISES THAT NEVER SEEM TO ARRIVE
For other voters, the frustration has been building for years, way before the Iran operation even showed up on the radar.
They heard promises about getting to the bottom of COVID-era decisions, the sham 2020 election, January 6, the Russia hoax, and all the lawfare that took down Trump and his supporters. They expected answers, accountability, and results. And Washington hasn’t delivered enough of any of the three.
And then there was the SAVE America Act. Americans spent years screaming about election integrity and demanding basic reassurance that their votes were being protected. Republicans controlled Congress and had an opportunity to show those voters they were being heard. But they couldn’t even get the legislation across the finish line.
What a slap in the face that was to voters who’d spent years demanding answers, accountability, and meaningful election reforms. Passing the bill wouldn’t have magically resolved every concern about American elections, but it would’ve sent a powerful message that Washington was finally taking those concerns seriously.
Instead, those voters watched another Republican promise run straight into a brick wall, even with their own party in charge, and bipartisan support for the bill.
CBS found Republican voters were much less confident that non-citizens voters would be kept from voting, even though large majorities of voters said they were confident their own ballots would be counted accurately.
And when voters lose faith in the people they’ve been showing up and voting for, eventually, they stop showing up.
THE PRICE OF STAYING HOME
A frustrated Republican voter can decide the party hasn’t earned another vote. Somebody else can decide the Democrats deserve a chance, or cast a protest vote out of spite. Others will stay home because, as they see it, nothing ever changes.
But here’s the problem with sitting out an election to teach your own party a lesson: The other side is still showing up. And Democrats certainly had plenty of reasons to be motivated. Their voters were angry about Trump, his policies, government corruption, and what they see as a president behaving more like a king than an elected official.
That’s why we can’t chalk this entire bloodbath up to Republicans staying home. Democrats were fired up, too, and they showed up ready to make their voices heard. Any serious autopsy of Tuesday night’s disaster has to account for both sides of that equation.
As we mentioned earlier, one huge problem was that Trump’s 2024 coalition didn’t hold together. Early AP voter research showed weaker Republican support among younger and Hispanic voters. We’ll need more detailed voting numbers to know just how many Republicans stayed home and how many actually crossed over to vote Democrat. But either way, Republicans have a much bigger problem on their hands than simply getting people off the couch on Election Day. They’re losing the confidence of voters they once counted on, and that’s going to take a lot more than a few campaign rallies to fix.
Tuesday was a blue wave, a red puddle, and an absolute political bloodbath for Republicans. The scale of this defeat is staggering, and with more races still being counted, the damage could get so much worse. There’s no spinning this into something less ugly than it is, and anybody trying to do that is only making the problem worse.
Democrats understood that their voters were angry. Republicans need to start asking why so many of theirs were, too. And that includes President Trump, who needs to reconnect with the populist, America First message that brought millions of Americans into his movement.
Those voters didn’t sign up for endless foreign wars, lavish White House ballrooms, or a Washington establishment that’s ignoring Americans who are struggling to pay their bills. They wanted somebody who fights for them, puts America first, and remembers what life looks like outside the Beltway.
And that’s where Trump is in real danger of losing something that once made him so politically formidable: his connection to regular Americans. The last thing anybody expected was for the billionaire who made a career out of taking on the elites to start looking like one of them.
We still believe Trump has it in him to regroup, listen to his voters, and come roaring back with the kind of populist energy that built MAGA. But right now, he’s off his game, and Tuesday night’s devastating results should leave absolutely no doubt about that.
Because the worst response to a political bloodbath this huge would be to pretend nobody bled out.
NEWSFEED — FOLLOW ON X — GAB — GETTR — TRUTH SOCIAL — BLUESKY
