The U.S. Supreme Court handed the Trump administration a setback Monday in a fight over tens of millions in research funding.
Advertisement
The justices declined to hear the administration’s appeal in a one-line order that gave no explanation and listed no dissents.
The dispute concerns University of California research grants targeted for cancellation under Trump’s orders on diversity, equity, and inclusion.
The decision leaves a federal injunction in place that blocks cancellation of certain grants within the University of California system.
Advertisement
The legal dispute centers on where the government’s discretion over taxpayer dollars ends and researchers’ First Amendment protections begin.
The Justice Department asked the justices to review a May ruling from a panel of the Ninth Circuit.
That panel upheld the injunction after finding the grant terminations likely violated the First Amendment.
In their ruling, the judges said the terminations “aimed to suppress viewpoints with which the government disagrees.”
That finding made the administration’s reasons for withdrawing support central to the case brought by the University of California researchers.
The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the appeal leaves those First Amendment questions unresolved.
The Justice Department argued that the federal government has “significant discretion” in deciding where taxpayer dollars go.
Solicitor General D. John Sauer argued that the Constitution allows Washington to stop funding research that promotes ideologies it opposes.
Sauer said officials could decide a project no longer served the public interest based partly on the viewpoint it advanced.
The administration’s position would give federal agencies greater room to reevaluate existing grants when a president changes federal spending priorities.
The appeals panel examined whether officials used their authority over federal research funds to suppress viewpoints protected by the Constitution.
The fight began in June 2025, when researchers within the University of California system challenged the planned loss of funding.
Advertisement
Those researchers had received multiyear research awards from three federal agencies for work they had already begun.
Federal officials informed them that they would abruptly cut their funding under several executive orders issued by President Donald Trump.
The cancellations would have ended support that researchers had expected to receive across multiple years of work.
Their lawyers called the cuts a “devastating blow” and warned that losing the grants could force research laboratories to close.
Advertisement
They also warned of layoffs and stalled research, saying the losses could reach staff and graduate and postdoctoral students.
The researchers’ lawyers urged the Supreme Court to turn away the appeal and leave the lower courts’ protection in place.
Their filing said grant recipients had relied on the awards when making decisions about staffing and conducting their research projects.
The lawyers argued that losing funding and personnel could stop researchers from publishing their findings and contributing to public debate.
“This is a quintessential First Amendment violation,” the researchers’ lawyers wrote to the justices.
The researchers’ case framed the loss of federal funding as a threat to their ability to publish and influence debate.
For the administration, the grants raised a broader question about whether taxpayers must keep funding projects officials no longer support.
Advertisement
Trump moved against DEI programs early in his second term, signing executive orders targeting diversity initiatives across federal agencies.
Those orders also reached the military and other federally funded institutions as the administration sought to eliminate diversity initiatives.
The California researchers’ challenge put the application of that wider policy to specific grants before the federal courts.
The injunction applies to certain grants within the university system, keeping those awards protected while the legal challenge proceeds.
It is a preliminary measure that the appeals panel reviewed in May before the Trump administration petitioned the Supreme Court.
Monday’s order leaves that ruling in place and offers no account of the justices’ views on the disputed funding decisions, The Hill reported.
The researchers warned that closed labs and lost jobs could result if agency officials abruptly ended the grants.
This article may contain commentary which reflects the author’s opinion.
